I titled this blog based on my experience in discussing life and wisdom with an elder who really surprised me the other day. In fact, my conversation with her has changed the way that I look at life, and especially the way I see older people now.
Some of the conventional wisdom, especially “new age” nonsense, was basically stood on its head during our talk. This tiny old lady named Dora set me straight on a lot of misunderstandings about life. What she spoke seemed to be the truth, in the way that our ears recognize what is right even when our brain is saying “No, no way!”
One thing I’ll say about Dora – she sure is crabby! But there is truth even in her crustiness itself. She’s more than earned it. I go over there at least once a month. Each time, she allows herself to show her impatience with the likes of me and my “stupid” questions. But she clearly loves my visits. The way that Dora utterly accepts herself and her perpetually shitty mood, is also truth, at least to me. This is why I can’t get enough of talking to Dora. She’s delightful and about 95 years old, although she won’t tell me her age.
The other day I went over there for coffee, armed with what I felt were pretty important questions about life, wisdom, and peace. I was well-prepared for Dora’s special brand of wisdom, as I had thickened my own skin and steeled my self-esteem, ready to take that predictable assault on my self-importance. It seems I need that, sometimes – like everybody else. We settled in and she regarded me with a frown.
“Dora, how does one attain inner peace?”
“What the hell do you mean by inner peace?!” she said.
“Well, I mean ‘enlightenment’, or ‘access to universal wisdom’. Like what the new-age gurus teach us is the ultimate goal of meditation.”
As usual, once she understood the question, the first thing Dora did was to roll her eyes and shake her head, snickering. How stupid I was to ask such a thing!
“Oh, man, where can we start. Lord Tunderin JEEZ-us sake. You want to know why I always stay the same inside, no matter what happens to me, is that it?”
I was stymied for a response … I hadn’t meant her. I didn’t mean “Dora how can I be more like you?” It never occurred to me that Dora had inner peace, not by the way she scoffed at me but still was always glad to see me. I never would have thought her to be enlightened. No guru would approve of her outbursts, I was quite sure.
She took my silence to mean a “yes” and proceeded to let me in on her secret. As she started, I could see a real rant developing and I dared not interject. Once, I interrupted her while on a rant and had an ashtray thrown at my head for my trouble. I think she missed me on purpose, though. She had a harsh, but effective, way of imparting her lessons – I never interrupted her again.
“Everybody’s always wanting a shortcut! Always wanting to find everything there is to find, right now already! Always wanting to know all that there is to know, like wisdom’s a stupid plastic toy made in China! JEEZus Keeeee-rist, you kids really burn me sometimes. You want wisdom from me, so that you can go and sell it, right? You want to write a book, is that it now? Write a book and make lots of money off of Dora’s words. I know you. I know you! Fuck off, you little bugger. Now listen. I can’t show it to you. I can’t teach it to you. All right? I can’t make you understand. That’s the answer to your question.”
She sat back with a rare, smug smile on her face. “More coffee dear?” She got up from her chair in an agonizingly slow step-by-step crawl which involved grasping the arm of the chair with both hands, and yelping with pain. I did my usual thing and half got to my feet, to help her, but as always, I was waved off.
“Don’t think I could go and get a pot of coffee for my guest? Think I’m USELESS, do ya? Quit insulting me and sit the hell back down.”
Fifteen minutes later, I had a cup of coffee and a piece of dried-up, rubbery chocolate cake without any icing. I hadn’t had the heart to tell Dora that I didn’t need “more coffee” since I hadn’t had any yet. Her way of offering anything was always to say, “More coffee?” and she’d often come back with tea, or on one memorable occasion, juiceboxes.
We settled in after Dora made four or five trips to the kitchen and back, refusing any offers of help with simply a thunderous, threatening glance in my direction if I so much as moved a muscle during the entire process.
“OK, Dora, I’m sorry but I really did not understand your answer at all.” I waited for the cursing to flow my way. But this time, it didn’t. Something very different happened … Dora got a peaceful look over her face for a change. I wondered if she’d wet her pants or something, she suddenly just looked so content, and …. blank. She looked just like the Dalai Lama with a half-smile and her head cocked to the side. This was the most surprising thing that had ever happened yet at Dora’s.
“My dear, nobody’s ever asked me that before. You made me think! I love you for that. You made me remember about my gifts – sometimes I forget. So many ridiculous people around, sometimes you forget. So listen. Wisdom comes with age, and you’re too young yet.” She sat back as if she’d just given me a golden egg to pass to the world. Now I was getting a bit afraid. Dora wasn’t making any sense. I always knew the day would come, when Dora wouldn’t be here anymore to have “coffee” and verbal abuse with me. I dreaded that day and now, was it here? Would my next phonecall be to Car 87 to come get Dora?
“Um, well, I do know that wisdom comes with age. I was just wondering if you could share with me the secret of inner wisdom, inner peace. There are so many people who want this, they go to classes. They twist their bodies into impossible shapes, and then hold it. They buy books, they watch Oprah, they go to lectures and seminars and symposiums, always looking for a way to feel happy inside. And they never seem to find it, although they do spend a lot of money looking for it. There’s a whole industry sprung up around trying to find happiness. If they ever do find it, then a lot of people would be out of a job!”
Dora took a deep, deep breath and sighed a long sigh. She smiled again and this time, I saw a part of Dora which I’d never seen before. I saw past all the crusty crabbiness, the cursing, the impatience, the eye-rolling and I saw the real lady inside. She looked at me with crystal-clear eyes, showing a sharp intelligence and some amusement.
“Young people are mostly anxious, because they are learning. You can’t avoid this. Youth is full of anxiety and that’s the way it was meant to be. They are supposed to be wanting to know things. If they had inner peace, then they wouldn’t try to learn anything. Bit of anxiety never really hurt anybody. As long as they know they’ll be fed, and somebody is there to look after them, they’ll be fine. The older you get, the less anxiety you’re supposed to feel. That’s because you are learning, you learned how to learn and now you just learn. The more you learn, the less anxious you are supposed to feel. It doesn’t always work that way though, and that’s because of money.”
She sat back and let me digest her words. I silently had a bite of cake and a swallow of bitter, lukewarm coffee. She never offered me sugar or milk, for some reason, and I never dared ask for it. But this gentle lady here, I bet she’d get me some sugar, I reasoned. No! Don’t spoil the moment. Just sit and listen, and hope that I remember what she says.
Dora went on. “Money makes people anxious when they aren’t supposed to be. So that spoils the whole process of wisdom. There’s nothing that anybody can do about that, until people stop teaching their kids that money is the most important thing. Until then everybody will be stuck in a state of anxiety. And this is the way that the money-people want it. They want everyone to be anxious. This serves them well.”
Dora always referred to “money-people”, an amorphous, undefined group of people who were apparently running society, when railing against the sad state of the world. “But Dora, how can we change this? Is there any way to change the way people look at money?”
“Well,” she said slowly, “there is. But that’s not what we’re talking about right now. Right now we’re talking about wisdom. Listen, money never got to me. I never subscribed to money-anxiety in my lifetime. I always knew there’d be enough. I always knew we’d eat. I never doubted that I’d be fed. So money never affected me. Do you want me to tell you how things would be, if we were NOT ruled by money? Do you want me to tell you about this ‘inner peace’ thing you asked about? Or do you wanna talk about money?”
She said the last word with a snarl of the Dora whom I was used to. So I knew how to respond. “No, Dora, not talk about money, let’s talk about the way it should be, the way it’s supposed to be, instead.”
She sat back and rocked in her chair, smiling at the ceiling. “Well OK then. Nobody ever asked me before. It’s nice. The answer? It’s simple, my dear. You have to wait. You just have to wait.”
“Oh Dora, please forgive me, but wait for what?”
“For inner peace. You have to wait. You can’t just get it. You can’t just take it. And you definitely can’t learn it. You only have to wait.”
Now it was my time to sigh. “Dora, I still don’t get it. Forgive me. I don’t know what you mean.”
“Child, nobody can teach anybody else how to be peaceful inside. Nobody can give it to anybody else. Those ‘gurus’ you mentioned are either stupid, or they’re lying. Either they know this already, or they don’t. I don’t care which. Some people come across inner peace and happiness at a relatively young age … others have to wait a very long time. Some people never, ever find it and they die without it. It all depends.”
She stopped, regarding me carefully and with a great deal of amusement, knowing what question I would ask next: “Depends on what, Dora? What does it depend on?”
“It depends on trouble.”
She smiled again, enjoying my confusion. She knew she was being obscure and unclear, and she was doing it on purpose. But I didn’t mind. This was normally how our discussions went – lots of anticipation, a great degree of mystery, right up until the very end, prolonging our visits as much as possible. Here was vintage Dora. We fell into our usual routine of questions and answers.
“What kind of trouble, Dora?”
“Any kind of trouble. The more trouble a person gets, the sooner they get to realize that none of it changes them inside unless they choose that. Do you understand, dear?”
“Um, maybe sort of. But not really. Life is full of trouble for everyone, but hardly anybody seems to be happy.”
“Well that’s because of money, but we’re supposed to be talking about a world where money is incidental, not primary. Let’s go back to our imaginary world by thinking about, oh I don’t know, how about Africa. Look at an African person and try to imagine their troubles. They don’t sit and dream about money. If they have food, they are happy. If their children eat, they are happy – that’s all it is. Some Africans kids at age 14 are already a LOT more wise and peaceful inside, than any western modern adult. So you need to imagine Africa when we are talking about this.”
“OK Dora – I am imagining Africa now. So, in this Africa, some people have inner peace and some don’t, is that right?”
“Yes – you got it! Those Africans who have plenty of trouble achieve inner peace sooner than others who have led easy lives. That’s because trouble makes you learn and it makes you strong, and able, and flexible. Once you learn that you really have no control, only then will you have complete control.”
“OK, Dora so we have to accept that we are not in control, is that it?”
“Well, that’s part of it, an important part. But it’s not the answer, it’s only a symptom of having the answer. People who have inner peace have long ago stopped trying to control their environment. But that’s not what gave them peace and happiness – that’s what happens once they’ve attained peace and happiness. See? It’s a symptom of being there.”
“OK, I think I see. So you get inner peace and happiness once you’ve had enough trouble? Assuming that you don’t have anxiety about money?”
“That’s it!” Dora’s grin was the same as a delighted five year old, pure, wide, and innocent. “You’ve got it now. Can you see now how this could never be taught to anybody? How can you teach somebody to be still on the inside? How can you teach somebody to be old? That only comes once you’ve learned again and again, that no matter what happens to you, you are still alive. You are still here. No matter how much trouble others cause you, none of it needs to change you. No matter what life throws your way, you can still stay you. You can still always be the same you, no matter what. “
“But Dora, the new-age gurus always say that you need to ‘let go of your ego’ and that the ‘ego’ is the you, the personality, the self-identity. They are always telling people to let go of that.”
“Well, then they are worse idiots than I thought. How can somebody abandon their inner personality? That’s ridiculous and by the way, it’s also impossible. I guess they love to waste everybody’s time. No – that’s wrong. Because no matter what, you always have to hang on to you. You have to remain you no matter what experiences, what troubles, you have. The older you get, the more troubles you have. The more troubles you’ve had, the more peace you get on the inside.”
“So wisdom comes with life experiences then, right?” I was slightly disappointed and I felt deflated. All that for nothing? After all, “Wisdom comes with experience” is a common phrase, something that you hear all the time. And this entire discussion only led to that? I felt ripped off, like I’d been led down the garden path at my own expense. I felt myself frowning, and Dora noticed.
“There there, don’t feel too stupid now,” Dora laughed. Then she began to cough and sputter, her eyes watered, and I sprang to my feet to assist her. Typically, she waved me off and continued to sputter. “Ooooh, my, that’s funny! That’s hilar-i-ous, my GOD! Buzz off, and let an old lady laugh, would you?”
So I sat silently, feeling hurt, and I let her laugh and cough and sputter and cry, until she was done.
“There now, I haven’t had a good laugh like that in ages! Thanks for that, dear. Yes” – she cleared her throat and tucked in - “wisdom and inner peace, and all that good stuff that people are trying to buy, it just all comes in with age. That 14 year old African kid, who’s already had his life threatened, who lost his parents and who takes care of his little brother all on his own, who has seen things that no human should ever have to see – this kid is exactly the same as a little old man who’s seen it all. And believe me, now that this kid has survived all of that, nothing will ever phase him. Nothing will ever bother that kid again. No matter what happens to him, no matter what life throws him, he will always be exactly the same on the inside. Do you see? He is a happy person.”
“OK, Dora, forgive me, but I don’t know why this can’t be taught. Can’t we just imagine that we are that wise, happy kid in Africa? Can’t we put ourselves in his shoes, and enjoy that same inner peace that he has?”
“Oh,” Dora sighed heavily again, “I guess you still don’t get it. Why am I surprised? Why do I even bother? Jeeez.” She snorted in my general direction with her usual impatience. But I waited, because I knew that we were onto something important, and I didn’t want to set her off.
“The type of certainty that this 14 year old African kid has, is the same type of certainty that you get with old age, over here in the land of plenty. When you are old, your friends maybe have died. For sure your parents have died, maybe even some of your kids have died. People have come and gone. Babies have been born. Maybe you lost everything, maybe you lost your house or all your money at some point. Then maybe something good happened, and you were right back where you’d started again. It all happens, over time. You see? Old age brings a set of experiences which could never have happened to a younger person already. It is only this set of life experiences, of troubles, which could ever give you that complete sense of certainty that you will always be here, no matter what. “
“Oh, I think I see – you can’t teach certainty. It can only happen on its own. If you try to teach an anxious person not to be anxious, usually that doesn’t work, right? The anxious person could only be self-taught in the ways of anxiety. Our inner life is our own. Only I can know myself on the inside. Nobody else could ever know me in that way.”
“Only I can know myself on the inside! That’s nice. Sweetie, you got it. Nobody knows the exact words to say to bring you peace. That’s because each of us is unique, everybody has had a unique set of life circumstances. So, nobody really knows how to reach you, or anybody else. Only you can reach yourself. This absolute certainly of who you are, that stillness, that inner quality which leaves you the SAME inside no matter what happens, this can only come with age. Because only with age can you collect all of those experiences which will teach you the one lesson – that you are still here. You are still alive, despite it all.”
I waited for the punchline, which I could sense was coming.
“And that’s why I said, that you have to wait. That’s why I said that I can’t show it to you, or teach it to you. That’s why I said that you’re too young yet. And that’s why I thank you, for reminding me about my gifts. My gifts …. the loss of my son, he died twenty years ago from cancer. The loss of my husband. That criminal who fooled me on the phone and took $500 of my money. Those neighbours who ganged up on me. My colleagues, way back when I was nursing, who gossiped about me. These are all my gifts. But sometimes you forget. These gifts of mine, they give me peace and they’ve made me happy. Thank you my dear, for reminding me that I am happy.”
Dora closed her eyes and leaned back her head, which was always my cue to leave. She was tired, but she was still going strong, I could see.
“OK Dora, well, thank for chatting. I’ll be back soon.”
“Good-bye dear. Thanks for giving me my gifts again,” she said without opening her eyes.
I let myself out.